Listen to the article
British musician Roger Waters, a former member of Pink Floyd, has recently become embroiled in controversy during his South American tour. Waters, who is known for his critical stance against the Israeli government, has faced accusations of anti-Semitism in Argentina.
The allegations surfaced following Waters’s claim that “the Israeli lobby” had prevented him from securing hotel accommodations in Buenos Aires and Montevideo. He expressed these concerns in an interview with Argentina’s Pagina 12 newspaper, alleging a coordinated boycott by pro-Israel groups.
The musician, who is touring with his “This Is Not a Drill” show, has drawn significant attention not only for his performances but also for his outspoken political views. In response to Waters’s claims, Carlos Broitman, an Argentine lawyer, filed a complaint against him with a federal court. Broitman contends that Waters’s visit to Argentina presents an opportunity for the artist to disseminate messages of hate and potentially incite anti-Semitic sentiments. Argentina, which boasts the largest Jewish population in Latin America, has been particularly sensitive to such issues.
In Uruguay, leaders of Jewish organizations have also expressed disapproval. The presidents of the Central Israelite Committee and B’Nai B’Rith NGO, Roby Schindler and Franklin Rosenfeld, respectively, have openly criticized Waters. They accuse him of propagating anti-Jewish hatred and have threatened to launch a campaign against the Sofitel Hotel chain if it hosts the musician.
The controversy has been further fueled by Waters’s past actions, including flying an inflatable pig with the Star of David during concerts and urging a cultural boycott of Israel. These actions have been interpreted by some as anti-Semitic, though Waters has consistently denied harboring any anti-Semitic beliefs, insisting his criticism is solely aimed at the Israeli government’s policies.
This situation has intensified with the recent October 7 attack by the Islamist group Hamas in Israel, resulting in significant casualties, including Argentine citizens. Waters’s comments casting doubt on the veracity of Israel’s statements about the attack have added to the tension.
The issue has garnered international attention, with the US State Department and the European Union’s anti-Semitism official criticizing Waters for using what they consider anti-Semitic tropes. Waters, who also faced scrutiny for wearing a seemingly Nazi-inspired costume at a Berlin concert, defended his actions as anti-fascist statements. However, these actions have been met with skepticism and condemnation by various groups and officials.
As Waters continues his tour, scheduled to visit countries including Chile, Peru, Costa Rica, Colombia and Ecuador, the debate surrounding his political views and the accusations of anti-Semitism persist, reflecting broader tensions and sensitivities related to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
With AFP
